Wouldn't be me denying it at this point, I'm alright with reserves so long as it's monitored and doesn't just incentivize people to faction-hop by making them officer+
If you are re-adding reserves then I recommend looking at the thread if you haven't already, there were a lot of good ideas suggested to counteract those issues with reserves.
care to shoot me a link? I have left the suggestion forums entirely to the managers of each respective forum and haven't been involved with their acceptance/denials