Both sides make good arguments based on the "old" rules (the rules that were up previously before now). In the past, it has always been you can kidnap even withotu a gun out, but whoever made the argument that you are a civilian with keys out and therefore should not be able to kidnap as one makes a sound point. However, with the rules (hopefully) being changed, there will be no more 2nd ROE of the sort. Up to this point, I find the "archives" and kidnapping for intel and finding out how people are dressed to be quite pointless, and has only created more trouble than good (eg. this thread and Conway's). I'm not saying they are inherently wrong reports, but petty.
When someone "metagames," I'm looking for a report on someone who did something to affect the outcome of the server, like using OOC info during war to push an objective, not call out models that he knew were GRU in his comms chat, got kidnapped anyway, and only got reported for the minuscule "infraction."
A lot of the staff's/potential staff's behavior in this thread was sub-par and will affect your evaluation as a staff member.
Denied.