Alright, so it'd always been the way of the Civil Protection life that if you see someone raiding, you blast 'em; if you see someone mugging, you blast 'em, Et cetera. Sometime between the time I was staff and when I started playing again recently, this changed. According to staff, the "You may not perform illegal activities" clause in the CP rules means you can't kill outright while countering illegal activities. Instead, you must arrest them.
However, when you counter a raid on civilian(another class with a 'no illegal activities' clause), you get to use your bang sticks as much as you want! It would be awesome if we could get a rule added in the CP rule section that states you have to make an attempt to arrest an evildoer, and only if they shoot you may you use lethal force.
Personally, I think it would make playing Civil Protection more fun if you could just blast people who are in the midst of a crime. I think it would fit the absurdity of the DarkRP genre much better than the current rule does.
Let me lay out a situation: There's a thief raiding Johnny's gun shop. You, as a member of the Civil Protection, see that the thief is two fading doors into Johnny's defense and, because of the arrest-not-kill rule, are powerless to do anything while the thief ransacks Johnny's shop. Now Johnny is indebted to the mafia, as he can't pay off his loan. Now Johnny is going to get kneecapped and will have to do his business out of a wheelchair.
How does that make you feel?
Alright, I digress. The rule is a somewhat reasonable attempt to enforce arrests, but in my opinion it's impractical and not communicated well AT ALL. Seriously, cops on DarkRP can't kill raiders or muggers without them shooting first because of this rule.
The resolution:
Either make it clear that CP's are not allowed to shoot first in any situation, or let DarkRP be DarkRP.