pd raid rules

[mossly 144]

description: mayor is literally just a "how long until you get rdmed" game. people raid the pd just to kill cops and the mayor, thereby creating a pd ebb and flow without allowing any real tension to build.

suggestion:

 

Require a reason for PD raid and advance notice of 5min or so. It lengthens mayor time, increases drama and planning, and makes more sense.

Example reasons: 

-Remove law 4 (warned 5 mins ahead of time to give an opportunity to acquiesce)

-TAXES TOO HIGH (5 min); for this to work a threshold needs to be set that is "raidably high"

-freeing compatriots

etc.

For this to work, the reasons would need to be codified in the rules.

 

The cooldown ensures both sides are prepared whilst giving mr mayor an opportunity to capitulate to their demands. Needing a reason means that the mayor can actually interact with constituents rather than hiding. 

I think the forced stakes and organization will create a better RP environment and entice people to actually defend the PD and feel like their raids or defenses thereof have longer lasting effects. Raid cooldown like 20min or something

 

On top of this, mayor unable to remayor for 30min. 

Raiding the PD needs to be more than "legal rdm"

[StraightWhiteChristianMale 563]

-1 takes away freedom and overcomplicates pd raids

[mossly 144]

3 minutes ago, StraightWhiteChristianMale said:

-1 takes away freedom and overcomplicates pd raids

It would add some level of complexity to pd raids, but it would by no means overcomplicate them

[ChrisRid 900]

-1

While I do really like this idea, the reason for my -1 is for the added difficulty in terms of moderation. I think it would add a great dynamic to the RP aspect and I like the examples that you have given of ways in which the Mayor might react (such as lowering taxes, or abolishing a law, etc) as this is an interesting take. It's just that I can see a massive increase in reports with reasons such as "raided PD before 5 mins was up" or "I removed the law and they still raided the PD" or "adverted raid but didn't give any reason" or even "RDM? I was countered in the 5 mins before I could raid the PD". So it will undoubtably add a large number of additional reports. Plus when it comes to raid timers (cooldown etc) they definitely have a place, nobody wants to be raided repeatedly, but where possible I think it's better to avoid additional timers for simplicity and speed of handling reports. Like I say though, it's a great suggestion but just a little difficult to moderate perhaps  

[mossly 144]

2 minutes ago, ChrisRid said:

-1

While I do really like this idea, the reason for my -1 is for the added difficulty in terms of moderation. I think it would add a great dynamic to the RP aspect and I like the examples that you have given of ways in which the Mayor might react (such as lowering taxes, or abolishing a law, etc) as this is an interesting take. It's just that I can see a massive increase in reports with reasons such as "raided PD before 5 mins was up" or "I removed the law and they still raided the PD" or "adverted raid but didn't give any reason" or even "RDM? I was countered in the 5 mins before I could raid the PD". So it will undoubtably add a large number of additional reports. Plus when it comes to raid timers (cooldown etc) they definitely have a place, nobody wants to be raided repeatedly, but where possible I think it's better to avoid additional timers for simplicity and speed of handling reports. Like I say though, it's a great suggestion but just a little difficult to moderate perhaps  

I think that removing the 5 min but still requiring a reason would also go a long way. 

[Shizzle 215]

-1 i like nerve gassing cops for no reason, plus it adds some edge to being mayor as some already last for hours.

[1998Corolla 333]

-1

Shouldn't need an incentive to raid a base or the PD, the PD vault should be incentive enough for someone wanting to raid. Some people will raid PD for the vault, some do it just because, and I have seen others saying "remove taxes or get raided". 

[WohMi 182]

-1

With the creation of the PD vault, there is now a legitimate reason to raid PD besides just killing the mayor.

[Salteeeens 277]

-1 i like to raid PD just because its the PD 

[IAreGunner 266]

-1 if it aint broke dont fix it

[Chawhead 135]

-1 makes no sense at all. people raid the pd to let people out of jail and for the vault

[stretchy 725]

Denied

Not enough community support.